With Mikey Garcia, a former featherweight, about to challenge full-fledged welterweight Errol Spence Jr. on Saturday, the factor of weight is on the minds of boxing fans. Though one might ask, “When is it not?” In recent years there have been numerous controversies revolving around weight cutting, or manipulating weight limits. Whether it’s Floyd Mayweather intentionally coming in overweight against Juan Manuel Marquez in 2009, or Canelo Alvarez insisting on catch-weights in different fights, or Adrien Broner and Julio Cesear Chavez Jr. repeatedly demonstrating complete contempt for weigh-ins, all demonstrate the fact that boxers often seek to gain an edge by forcing an opponent to dry out, or by bringing some extra pounds into the ring.
Obviously an unfair advantage exists if one pugilist has made the necessary sacrifices to reach the required weight and the other has not. But that said, some fans may be surprised to learn that some of the greats of the past regarded weigh-ins and weight advantages as things that had about as much bearing on their practice as the relative humidity or a boxer’s shoe size. According to countless reports, gladiators like Sam Langford, Mickey Walker and Jimmy Wilde never turned away a challenge on the basis of their opponent’s size and poundage.
And so it was for the first Joe Walcott, not to be confused with heavyweight champion Jersey Joe Walcott, the latter naming himself after the legendary ring warrior who he regarded as the greatest fighter who ever lived. The original Walcott was born on this day in the Barbados but grew up with his family in Massachusetts, where as a youth he worked at various jobs including helping to sweep up in one of Boston’s many fight clubs. It wasn’t long before Walcott began training and sparring and his natural abilities came to the fore. He turned pro in 1890 at the age of 17 and within five years had established himself as one of the sport’s most fearsome battlers, the writers of the day pegging him as the hardest-hitting welterweight in the world.
Walcott’s abilities stemmed in large part from his physical gifts which had nothing to do with size and weight and everything to do with natural strength, power, stamina and durability. Standing under 5’2″, Walcott sported a massive upper body for his stature with an 18 inch neck, a 41 inch chest, and long, powerful arms. Nat Fleischer described him as a “sawed-off Hercules” and “an abnormally powerful puncher.” The National Police Gazette marveled at Walcott’s power, stating that one clean strike from Joe was equal to five from his opponent.
Similar to other black fighters of the time such as George Dixon, Joe Gans or Sam Langford, it was extremely difficult for Walcott to secure a shot at a world title, or to get a fair shake. Having established himself as one of the best welterweights in the world, the current champion, Tommy Ryan, avoided him, forcing Walcott to try for Kid Lavigne’s lightweight title in 1897. Drained by the effort to make weight, Walcott dropped a close decision. The following year he lost another close decision in an attempt to win the welterweight title from fellow great “Mysterious” Billy Smith. Walcott eventually got another shot at the welterweight belt when he faced Jim (“Rube”) Ferns in 1901 and this time Walcott won by a knockout in round five. He kept the title until 1904, when he lost to the legendary Dixie Kid by controversial disqualification (it was later established the referee had bet on Dixie) in the first world title match between two black boxers.
But as any boxing historian knows, championships had little to do with true boxing greatness during Walcott’s era. For example, boxing legend Sam Langford received only one try at a title, a 15 round war with Walcott which ended in a draw, but he is regarded by most as one of the greatest fighters of all time. Instead, it is Walcott’s many fights against much larger men that sets him apart as a genuine immortal of the ring. Frustrated by the difficulties in securing matches against the best welterweights of the day, Walcott issued public demands to take on the better big men instead, and when given the chance, amazingly, he usually bested his much taller and heavier opponents. Fittingly, it is Walcott who is credited with the timeless maxim, “The bigger they are, the harder they fall.”
To illustrate, Walcott’s manager, Tom O’Rourke, also handled Sailor Tom Sharkey, a top heavyweight contender of the time who twice went the distance with heavyweight champion James J. Jeffries. O’Rourke stated that he had to stop Walcott from sparring with Sharkey because Joe kept knocking Sailor Tom down. Another example: the August 28, 1895 Boston Herald reported that Walcott weighed just 138 pounds against Dick O’Brien’s 155, but O’Rourke was so confident in his fighter that he waived the weight. Walcott knocked out O’Brien in the first round. Walcott also beat a number of top middleweights including Jack Bonner, Tommy West, Kid Carter, George Cole, and Joe Grim. He fought light heavyweight champ George Gardner twice in non-title tilts, winning once by 20 round decision.
But perhaps the best example of Walcott’s amazing ability to defeat much larger men is his win over Joe Choynski, a formidable heavyweight who had competed with the likes of Jim Corbett, Bob Fitzsimmons and Jack Johnson. Choynski outweighed Walcott by some 30 pounds and was a five-to-one favorite but Walcott showed his incredible power and strength in flooring Choynski multiple times en route to winning by a seventh round stoppage. The contemporary equivalent of this would be say Errol Spence Jr. or Shawn Porter taking on Eleider Alvarez or Murat Gassiev and winning by knockout. Just pause for a second and consider that.
Walcott’s ring immortality is based on such amazing feats, as well as the esteem he was held in by his contemporaries. Heavyweight champion Jack Johnson rated Walcott as one of the most powerful hitters of the time. Langford himself paid Walcott the great tribute of ranking him the hardest puncher he had ever faced in his incredibly long career. “He was the hardest hitter I ever met,” stated Langford, recalling their 1904 match which, according to reports, was a furious and action-packed 15 rounder. “Never before or since have I been hit as hard and as often … and I never landed more blows than I hurled into Joe Walcott that night.”
In 1904, Walcott injured his right hand in a gun accident and did not compete for two years. He returned to the ring greatly diminished before finally retiring in 1911. Unfortunately, Walcott had lived fast, squandering his ring earnings on the usual vices, and in his later years he struggled to get by before being hired as a custodian for Madison Square Garden. He died in 1935 after being struck by a car.
Both Nat Fleischer and Charley Rose rated Walcott as the best welterweight of all time and historian Monte Cox states that his “success against men of much higher weights leads one to believe that no modern welterweight could have gone the 20 round distance with him.” Doubtless, he forever stands as a true, pound-for-pound ring great and perhaps the best “giant killer” the sport has ever known. Case in point, even if Mikey Garcia bucks the odds and wins on Saturday, he would still have a long, long way to go to ever catch up to “The Barbados Demon.” — Michael Carbert