Fight City Legends: The Michigan Assassin

For middleweight legend Stanley Ketchel, the boxing ring was the only theater in which his mania could legally project its voice. Born in 1886 in Grand Rapids, Michigan, and orphaned at 14, the ‘Michigan Assassin’ travelled westward as a teenager, distinguishing himself as a feared street fighter in Montana’s tough-knuckled mining culture. Ketchel would parlay his brutal fists and pugnacious disposition into a successful professional boxing career, becoming middleweight champion in 1908. His blazing run ended prematurely with his murder at 24, but despite his brief time at the top he is ranked by some as the greatest middleweight of all-time. Simply put, Stanley Ketchel was one of the most vicious and devastating punchers to ever wear boxing gloves.

Drawing by Damien Burton

Fighting, aggression, and general boisterousness encapsulated Ketchel’s short life. From his days as a brawling youth to his time fighting in Montana bars, Ketchel’s identity was drawn from his ability to physically dominate other men. As an adolescent he knocked out a grown man in a boxing exhibition at a local fair and soon after he turned to boxing as a lucrative financial opportunity. It is estimated that before he turned professional in 1903, Ketchel battled in as many as 250 unsanctioned and doubtlessly brutal fights around Montana, during which he honed his skill and savagery. Whether as an amateur or pro, Ketchel always entered the ring with the same decisive look in his cold eyes, at once nervous and unshakably self-confident, prepared to acquit himself viciously in the vortex that was the early 20th century boxing ring.

Ketchel and Papke.
Ketchel battling Billy Papke.

Never formally trained, Ketchel didn’t possess exemplary technique. He wasn’t defensively skilled and often fought wide open, confident that his antagonistic style would prove too onerous for his opponent. Strong enough to knock someone out with either hand, Ketchel’s thirst for violence was supported by bottomless reserves of energy that allowed him to continue pressing at a desperate pace in the late stages of a contest. He was a furious, whirling dervish inside the ring, wholly intent on annihilating his opponent. According to manager ‘Dumb’ Dan Morgan, “Ketchel was an exception to the human race. He was a savage. He would pound and rip his opponent’s eyes, nose and mouth in a clinch. He couldn’t get enough blood.” Rarely serene, Ketchel’s impulsive, even psychopathic disposition, made his behaviour unpredictable. He often carried a gun, and when upset would flaunt it unabashedly.

Ketchel (right) poses with Hugo Kelly ahead of their 1908 tilt.

Ketchel ripped his way through the available competition in Montana, losing only twice in his first forty pro fights, with almost all of his wins coming by knockout. He then moved on to California, with its deeper well of boxing talent and opportunities to challenge for a title. There Ketchel’s career would ascend. Losing to Joe Thomas on points in a controversial decision, Ketchel won the rematch by knockout. This fight, considered by many to be one of the greatest in boxing history given its furious pace and changes of momentum, was followed by a third clash, which Ketchel won on points. And with the victory came the world’s middleweight championship. Fighting frequently, Ketchel successfully defended his title against the highly regarded Sullivan brothers, Mike and Jack, Billy Papke, and then Joe Thomas again.

Ketchel's power overwhelms another opponent.
Ketchel’s power overwhelms another opponent.

In his rematch with Papke, Ketchel would be blindsided by the challenger at the opening bell. This cheap shot, which gave rise to the famous referee’s order to “shake hands and come out fighting,” badly hurt the champ, and Ketchel succumbed by TKO in the twelfth round. Furious at the outcome, Ketchel avenged the loss in their third meeting, earning an eleventh round knockout, the only time in his career that Papke was counted out.

After vanquishing Papke, Ketchel headed eastward, twice fighting light heavyweight champion ‘Philadelphia’ Jack O’Brien. In the first match—a classic, competitive bout that was deemed a no decision—it’s possible that Ketchel actually knocked O’Brien out at the end of the tenth and final round. Fortunately for the Irishman, the bell saved him from being counted out, leaving the result in dispute. The outcome of their rematch would be less vague, however, as Ketchel finished O’Brien in three rounds. He then traveled back to California to again defeat Papke, this time by unanimous decision. This was merely a preamble, however, to his next bout against the legendary Jack Johnson.

Jack Johnson and Stanley Ketchell Fighting in Ring
Ketchel floors the great Jack Johnson.

As dangerous as Ketchel was, there was little chance he could beat “The Galveston Giant.” Winning shouldn’t have necessarily been Ketchel’s objective anyway, if he wanted to comply with the wishes of the motion picture company covering the bout, who wanted it to go an acceptable length for commercial purposes. This necessitated a more reserved style of boxing, which was anathema to Ketchel. Johnson fought in his usual, defensive manner, aware that he stood to receive a sizeable share of profits if the fight went long enough to conciliate the movie-going public. Ketchel, far too aggressive a soul to remain restrained, veered from the script when he hammered Johnson with a wild right in round twelve and sent him to the canvas. Johnson rose and immediately knocked Ketchel unconscious with a right hand of his own.

The great Stanley Ketchel.

After the Johnson episode, Ketchel fought five more times before his murder, earning a no decision, losing to Sam Langford, and winning three others, finishing his career with a record of 51-4-4. Only 24, Ketchel was murdered by a farm hand in Conway, Missouri, in October of 1910, for reasons apparently rooted in jealousy and financial gain. His last words, at odds with the fearless image he presented publicly, are said to have been, “Take me home to mother.”      — Eliott McCormick

5 thoughts on “Fight City Legends: The Michigan Assassin

  • June 14, 2019 at 11:22 am
    Permalink

    There was no cheap shot vs. Papke. That is a debunked myth. Great article otherwise

    Reply
  • August 17, 2019 at 1:08 pm
    Permalink

    Jack Johnson a menti en disant qu’il a voulu faire durer le combat et qu’il a été pris en traître. La vidéo complète démontre Que Johnson voulait lui aussi en finir vite. Ketchel avait le visage en sang et s’était retrouvé au tapis au sixième.
    https://www.boxing247.com/news/bearden2006.php
    On ose imaginer si Stanley avait été du même poids.

    Reply
  • November 21, 2019 at 3:01 pm
    Permalink

    Love to see him fight today. 32 round fights, 20 round fights… Hell, he’d be just getting started by the seventh round when today’s fighters would be getting tired. When you leave home at 12 or 14 years old, you just gotta be one tough son-of-a-bitch!

    Reply
  • December 31, 2020 at 1:16 pm
    Permalink

    So now that I’ve been explained to as to why Stanley katchel was great. ( Thank you fight city for the history lesson) Im very curious now as to why Stanley was scared to death of Jack Blackburn. It’s said that Stanley katchel went out of his way to duck Blackburn. Seeing as how he was a terror in and out of the ring it’s very curious to me.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *