The popularity of pugislim has waxed and waned over the decades, but the 1950s saw a new source of anxiety emerge for the boxing biz: television. With boxing being featured on free TV on a regular basis, live cards saw their attendance figures drop and people in the fight crowd began to worry about their livelihoods. Add in the fact that the heavyweight division had been in the doldrums since the retirement of Rocky Marciano, with unpopular champions like Sonny Liston and Muhammad Ali turning off the general public, and it appeared to many that boxing was in serious trouble.
But in February of 1965 a strange and unexpected thing happened: a non-title fight that shouldn’t have attracted much attention outside of hardcore fans, became a major event with keen interest from sports fans and the mainstream media. The huge success of the battle between former champion Floyd Patterson and top contender George Chuvalo showed that boxing, despite everything, maintained a strong hold on the public imagination.
Perhaps this had something to do with the storyline of Patterson’s search for redemption. Floyd was Marciano’s successor and had never aroused the public’s passion. Polite and likable, he seemingly possessed none of the viciousness expected in a top prizefighter. When he was demolished in less than one round by a hulking ex-con and leg-breaker for the mob named Sonny Liston, the public felt bad for Floyd, a feeling only deepened when word came out of how after the fight the shamed ex-champion used a fake beard and glasses to exit the stadium unobserved.
In the rematch, Liston again disposed of Patterson in a single round. After a six month layoff, Patterson returned to the ring but the shame which inspired him to wear a cheap disguise after a defeat motivated him to begin his comeback on a different continent. He won three fights in Sweden, where because of his battles with Ingemar Johansson he was hugely popular; a fourth victory took place in Puerto Rico.
So perhaps the public’s interest in the Patterson vs Chuvalo match had to do with it being a homecoming for the former champion. Or maybe it was the fact it was an intriguing match-up between top contenders, with the winner promised a title shot by current champion Muhammad Ali. Whatever the reason, Madison Square Garden was sold-out, almost 300 press credentials had been issued, and on the night of the contest scalpers were doing brisk business along 8th Avenue. At ringside was a who’s who of former champions and celebrities including Joe Louis, Rocky Marciano, and Gene Tunney. The odds favoured Patterson slightly, at 7 to 5.
Thankfully, Patterson vs Chuvalo lived up to the hype. For 12 action-packed rounds, the former champion and the rising contender gave the big crowd a hell of a show, battling with an intensity rarely seen in heavyweight bouts. Chuvalo concentrated on landing his heavy artillery on Patterson’s ribs, forcing the former champion to give ground. His advantages in weight and strength compelled Patterson to alter his strategy; instead of trying to bring his left hook into play behind an aggressive attack, Patterson had to box and move. Thus, Floyd’s edge in hand speed enabled him to take advantage of openings and counter Chuvalo’s body punches with stinging combinations.
Chuvalo shook Patterson in the fourth and sixth rounds while the former champ repeatedly landed sharp right hands. In the eighth he connected with a series of flush rights that had the crowd roaring, but Chuvalo never wavered, his granite chin as solid as ever.
By the late rounds, it was clear Patterson had the advantage. George’s body attack, while effective, just wasn’t paying the big dividends he expected. Still, round ten was maybe Chuvalo’s best of the fight as he got home with a continuous volley of punches, almost knocking Floyd down, but Patterson recovered and the pace in the last two rounds was blistering, with the former champion’s hand speed allowing him a slight edge. The judges gave Patterson a close but unanimous decision victory.
Afterwards Chuvalo complained that referee Zack Clayton prevented him from executing his strategy. “Every time I started to get going, the referee would break us up. He just wouldn’t let me fight my fight.” The loss was heartbreaking for Chuvalo, who had yet to receive a chance at the world title. For Patterson, his big win was a measure of sweet vindication after the shame of his knockout defeats to Liston. Muhammad Ali would follow through on his promise and defend his crown against Patterson the following November, stopping Floyd in round 12 in a one-sided bout.
— Michael Carbert